Annual Meeting Minutes November 14, 2026
SUMMERPLACE IMPROVEMENT ASSOCIATION, INC. Annual Meeting Minutes
SATURDAY NOVEMBER 14, 2026, 10:00AM
Held at 1995 W. BAREFOOT PL.
The Meeting was called to order at 10:06am
Introduction of Board members – the 5 current Board members introduced themselves and their roles. Michael Flax – President, John Finn – Vice President, John Lehnhardt – Secretary/Treasurer, Walter Garrard and Steve Melchiori.
New association members – Kathleen and Joseph Wilson of Davie, Florida introduced themselves. They have just inherited the lot at 1840 E. Pebble Path from Glen O’Hearn, of Port St. Lucie, who had owned it for over 30 years and recently passed away at 94. They are considering options for either building a home on the site or selling the lot. The will be applying for membership through the normal application process as required for non-spousal property inheritance rules in our founding documents.
Loren Smith, who purchased the lot tab 1990 W. Barefoot Pl. last year and completed her new house last winter, introduced herself as it was her first time attending the annual meeting.
Calling of the Roll – Secretary – Determination of Quorum – laws requires 30% of the membership for a quorum, present in person or by proxy. SIA needs 21 of its 69 members for a quorum.
The members role call resulted in 27 in person members and 12 member proxies, or a total of 39 members counting as present. This well exceeds quorum requirements and the business meeting was approved to move ahead.
Submission of proof of notice of meeting notification – Secretary Lehnhardt submitted the required Affidavit of Proof of Notification that packets were mailed to members at their listed mailing addresses September 24, 2026 and the full packet of information was posted on the SIA website and Bulletin Board the same day. This Affidavit will be maintained for one year per state law.
Report of Officers: Treasurer – 2026 financial report – at the end of the fiscal year, Sept. 30, 2026, the SIA accounts had a balance of $33733.31 after an opening FY balance of $58,984.86. The operating budget had a surplus of $6,981.34 out of a budget of $22,200. Capital expenditure for E. Shell stair repairs was $3893.96. Capital expenditures for the road resurfacing was $29,815. Total capital expenditures were $33,708.96 out of a capital budget of $40,000.
2026-27 budget approval vote – the proposed operating budget for 2026-7 was discussed. It include the total income expected from 2027 dues of $300 per lot or $22,200, with projected expenses of $15,470 and a $6,730 contingency fund. We are awaiting final bids from Dockside Builders on repair of the three damaged sets of stairs but preliminary estimates came in around $20,000 for the total repairs. This a $20,000 capital expenditure is included in the proposed budget. (we just received the final bid for stair repairs – $21,645 for the three – the budget contingency can cover the additional over the budgeted capital cost)
A question was raised by one of the newer members around the stair repairs due to the frequency of damages and whether any cost analysis had been done to see if something more lasting and more expensive could be installed. Long term members have been through this issue many times and commented that we have looked at many options, none of which guarantee success over the long term. Historically we have built, often ourselves, low cost steps that we can afford to do on an annual basis within our budget restraints. Major installation of stairs at points on the seawall have cost $40,000 to $70,000 per set, which would then cost SIA $120,000 to $210,000. That is 6 to 10 times our annual budget at our current dues rate. It was suggested by members that we increase our dues or make additional assessment to cover these costs, which would be somewhere between $1700 – 3000 per lot.
It was moved and seconded and approve unanimously by member show of hands to accept the budget as proposed with the $20,000 capital expense to repair the stairs.
Committee reports:
Maintenance Committee – VP John Finn reported that the Shell beach access stairs were repaired in February by Dockside Builders and the roads were refinished in July by Bill Pinheiro. John was able to retain Bill who had done our road work in the past and was well respected by our members but dropped off the map for a while. Bill will come back each six months to regrade the roads.
Architectural Review Committee – the primary work of the committee was to participate in an 8 person ad hoc committee to draw up a new version of the ARC Guidelines that was requested at an open meeting this summer and approved to move forward by the SIA Board . The final draft of this proposal took many many hours of work to agree upon and was distributed to the membership in the annual mailing. It was also sent to our SIA Attorney for review. Three members took the time to write notes to the board that raised significant concerns about certain aspects they felt were contradictory within the document itself, potentially in conflict with Florida law concerning fee structures, and in conflict with our founding documents. The Board noted these concerns and forwarded them to our attorney. Because our attorney had not weighed in on the proposal by the time of the annual meeting, Steve Melchiori made a recommendation that the proposed ARC Guideline be tabled until legal concerns could be addressed. He proposed that all members, in the mean time, review the document, send their comments to the Board in writing and the Board would distribute them to the members. Then the new Board would determine the best course of action.
A great deal of discussion ensued as a number of members wanted to speak about their concerns on this ARC draft at the meeting. There was significant concern that these new guidelines were far to extensive and complicated and felt like overreach for a small hopefully close knit community that was low key and allowed for great freedom of expression on their property without much oversight. Counter to that it was expressed that as a 501c3 LLC we are a business and should be run with greater controls.
A member of the committee that had been part of the development of the ARC Guidelines in 2011 argued that these were sufficient as written and needed no further enhancement.
One concern raised was that the new Guidelines referenced appendices that were not included in the mailing and thus the Guidelines could not be legally voted on.
A member who participated in the current ARC Guideline ad hoc review, who has extensive personal experience in association development, took it upon themselves, to reduce and refine the guidelines and submitted them to the Board independent of the committee. This member expressed their disappointment that their version was not used by the Board.
It became clear that there was great resistance to these new Guidelines. The question became whether to vote on them directly, or to vote on tabling them. In either situation, the current standing ARC Guidelines would remain in place unchanged. It was moved, seconded approved by a clear majority show of hands to table the proposed guidelines.
The new Board will determine whether or how to move forward with this project.
once legal opinions have been received.
New business – Update on the Septic conversion state law and its implementation in Indian River – State Law requires that all septic systems be connected to sewer systems or be upgraded to certain standards by 2030. The County is working to connect to its sewer system only those currently within a reasonable distance from existing sewer lines. Summerplace residences do not currently have access to the county system except for E. Shell Lane. County main sewer lines, both gravity and pressurized, run along A1A but do not extend down our streets, except for E. Shell Lane. There is no current plan to run the lines down our streets. Phil Glade attended a meeting some years ago with our County Commissioner where sewer lines were being proposed for Summerplace, but at the risk of destroying the oak tree canopy due to the installation. The Summerplace residents in attendance strongly rejected the plan. Phil Glade sent a list of options for conversion of septic systems to the Board. These will be posted on our website.
2026-7 SIA Board of Directors and Election results
A total of 39 Voter Certificate verified Ballots were cast. Two ballots were received without Voter Certificates and were not counted.
Alex Collazo – 33 votes
John Finn – 17 votes
Michael Flax – 34 votes
Walter Garrard – 33 votes
Renee Hall – 33 votes
Angelo Zaffuto – 27 votes
WRITE-IN CANDIDATES
Phil Glade – 1 vote
Lill Miller-Fox – 1 vote
Sharon Desimone – 1 vote
Alex Collazo, Michael Flax, Walter Garrard, Renee Hall, and Angelo Zaffuto are the SIA Board of Directors for the next year.
The meeting was adjourned at 11:45am
An organizational Executive Board Meeting of the newly elected directors immediately following the annual meeting. The new officers are:
President – Michael Flax
Vice President – Walter Garrard
Secretary – Renee Hall
Tresurer – Alex Collazo
Angelo Zaffuto was not present at the Executive Meeting or the Annual meeting